Boundaries of Compassion

by Manfred Clynes

I) A German Journey
II) Prolegomena for a Systems Answer

True music

Does not lie

Seduces only

To compassion

Rare true music

Will stop hatred

And violence, for a time

Beethoven's last Quartets

Begin to be True Music

Music that sounds

all the time

Try, if you will,

Indeed

Bondage and Discipline

Cannot be done

To Beethoven's Last Quartets

Nevertheless

Beethoven ate animals

Between symphonies

and laughed when the

Jewish Community wanted to commission him

Not enough joy for brotherhood

Not enough joy to erase the memories

Of habits of mind

Was die Mode streng geteilt

Joy and distraction are not enough

To detract man from his hates for long,

The fury for not being omnipotent

From injustice experienced

and committed

From his destruction

Joy by itself cannot endure

Unless fed by Love

Continuously

With a break only

For reverence,

For the source of love

This Beethoven did in his music

Precisely

But even he could not do it

In daily life

All the time.

Only the greatest music even begins

To be great enough

To start to erase our inflamed blind spot

Music is personal

But contains no address -

A fatal flaw

The default address we provide

Automatically acknowledges

Our blind spot

This deeply inflamed stain music

Needs to attack

To let love flow freely to the dark

unseen regions

To those

Not on our address file.

It could not do it for Beethoven

How would it

For the workers of Buchenwald ?

Our address system is fashioned by a different

Non-musical compiler

Music can only deliver the message

Not find the address

That is a gnostic function

Of Love itself

Writing its own evolution.